Julien Danjou • 5/10/2013

Rant about Github pull-request workflow implementation

Read Original

The article is a detailed critique of GitHub's pull request system, comparing it unfavorably to systems like Gerrit or email-based patch submission. The author argues that GitHub's simplified 'one-click' contribution model obscures the necessary iterative review process, encourages messy commit histories, and fails for substantial projects beyond trivial changes.

0 comments
#software development #github #version control
Rant about Github pull-request workflow implementation

Comments

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts!

Browser Extension

Get instant access to AllDevBlogs from your browser

Top of the Week

1
The Beautiful Web
Jens Oliver Meiert • 2 votes
2
When your coding agent doesn’t understand your project, you’ll get junk
Benjamin Cane • 1 votes
3
LLM Use in the Python Source Code
Miguel Grinberg • 1 votes
4
Wagon’s algorithm in Python
John D. Cook • 1 votes
5
An example conversation with Claude Code
Dumm Zeuch • 1 votes